Thursday, June 21, 2012

Census rewriting SC, ST narrative: shows increased material well-being


Census rewriting SC, ST narrative: shows increased material well-being

Wed Jun 20, 2012 11:47 pm (PDT)
Census rewriting SC, ST narrative....Anil Padmanabhan & Remya Nair Latest houselisting data demonstrates a visible growth in the material well-being of the two groups
New Delhi: Indians, all of them, across class and caste, traded up over the past decade, a period of rapid and record economic growth-that's the counter-intuitive message in the latest update to Census 2011.
According to the so-called houselisting data released by the census, scheduled castes (SCs) and scheduled tribes (STs) have, like the rest of the country, and allowing for some variations across regions, demonstrated a visible growth in their material well-being, especially in terms of their access to telecommunication and banking services-two key parameters to measure inclusion, or the effort to integrate the underdeveloped and underprivileged into the country's economic mainstream.
In March, the houselisting data released for the entire country showed a perceptible change in the lifestyle of the population in general, reflecting a silent but strong trend-trading up. The houselisting data collected along with the decadal census allows demographers to measure the level of the quality of life. The story that the data told was that of a rapidly expanding consumer economy.
According to the latest data release, among people belonging to SCs, access to banking services rose from about one of every four persons in 2001 to one in two in 2011; and to telephones, from three per 100 to one in two.
Similarly, for people belonging to STs, the proportion of those accessing banking services rose from a little under one in five persons in 2001 to a little under one in two in 2011; and telephones, from about two in 100 to one in three.
Interestingly, this change is seen most prominently in services that are universal in nature and which, especially in the case of telecom and banking, have seen active participation of private companies resulting in healthy competition. Such dramatic spurts are not visible with respect to other parameters such as the quality of roofing, and access to tap drinking water and electricity.
At the same time, the gap between people belonging to SCs and STs and others has narrowed. And this has coincided with the rapid political mobilization of these communities.
Narendra Jadhav, member of the Planning Commission and author of Untouchables, said the trend fits a narrative. "There is a change and there is no doubt about it. I have been saying this time and again that there is a silent revolution taking place among the SCs, if not STs. Their aspirations are taking flight; it is visible in the emergence of Dalit entrepreneurs and the trends visible in these (census) numbers. There is much greater transformation taking place than what we care to admit."
According to Jadhav, the trend also manifests itself in the broad-basing of the benefits. "I would go to the other extent and say that our long-term growth has been made possible because people who were not in the mainstream have come into it. The broad-basing of the benefits of growth has given birth to new stakeholders."
The numbers show that market-based systems can be employed to deliver certain class of services, say some experts. And that, in some instances, they work much better than government-authored welfare programmes for SCs and STs.
"It is a combination of increase in awareness levels among people as well as a push by banks to bring more people into the banking fold. Opening of bank branches in rural areas has increased awareness levels among the population. Migration and the need for people to access banking facilities to send and receive money have also played a major role in greater banking coverage," said Nachiket Mor, former chairman of the ICICI Foundation for Inclusive Growth.
And, in some cases, progress has been brought about by co-ordinated central planning. According to M.V. Nair, former chairman and managing director of Union Bank of India, who headed a Reserve Bank of India (RBI) panel for revising the definition and structure of priority sector lending, the trend reflects the financial inclusion drive pursued by RBI in the past 10 years.
"Since 2005, there have been a number of regulations such as the business correspondent model and other technology initiatives to ensure that every household that does not have access to banking services gets a bank account," he said. "Inevitably, schedule caste and schedule tribe households did not have access to banking services, either in rural areas or in slums in urban areas, and they benefited from this financial inclusion drive."
Some analysts were however cautious in reading too much into the numbers. N.C. Saxena, member of the National Advisory Council, said that most bank accounts had been opened by wage labourers participating in the government's marquee rural employment scheme and were largely not operational.
"There has been a great development for scheduled castes, and the gap between them and the general population is narrowing, but that is not true for scheduled tribes for whom it is diverging. Eighty per cent of people belonging to scheduled tribes live in central India. The data may be coming about because people from the scheduled tribes are doing very well in Himachal Pradesh and north-east states," he said.
And a much closer reading of the data and more research will be needed before any conclusion can be reached, said S. Japhet, director of the Centre for the Study of Social Exclusion and Inclusive Policy and professor at National Law School in Bangalore. "The increase in telephone (penetration) cannot be very indicative of a trading-up in material well-being as it's not known how the telephone connection is being utilized; as in...does the person use it to make outgoing calls or only stick to incoming calls?"

anil.p@livemint.com
Anuja contributed to this story. URL: http://www.livemint.com/2012/06/21005650/Census-rewriting-SC-ST-narrat.html

Death of a journalist: Putting one's life on the line


Death of a journalist: Putting one's life on the line

Wed Jun 20, 2012 11:45 pm (PDT)

Putting one's life on the line....Sevanti Ninan

Because it is an increasingly lawless country and because media competition pushes those who are sent to get the story to try harder, the risks are greater than before
India can be a rough country if you are practising something other than soft journalism. Last weekend's tragic death of a gifted young photographer from malaria and resulting complications has helped to focus attention on the risks and responsibilities.
Tarun Sehrawat worked for Tehelka and his death following an assignment in Abujmarh in Chhattisgarh has had colleagues in the profession raising issues of safety on the job and institutional structures that even the English language media has not put in place. The rougher things get in India, the more those covering the news will be at risk. They are the ones at the cutting edge of both big-city and district-level corruption, Naxalism, insurgency and much else.
Because it is an increasingly lawless country and because media competition pushes those who are sent to get the story to try harder, the risks are greater than before. Sehrawat's death has drawn attention, that of a mofussil journalist in Madhya Pradesh earlier this year has not. Looking at physical attacks so far this year shows in how many ways the tribe is vulnerable.
April alone saw three assaults on journalists and two attacks on media property. A Chhattisgarh journalist was attacked for exposing illegal forest felling, Nirmal Baba's supporters attacked journalists in Delhi, and railway staff manhandled a Navbharat Times reporter in Mumbai for clicking pictures of an illegal activity. In March, lawyers attacked journalists in Bangalore and in February a journalist in Cachar district was attacked for exposing corruption in the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme work. In January, Manipur journalists were on a pen-down strike to protest continuous threats by militants. How do we even begin to protect such people?
Health hazards then were the last things anybody was looking at. As both Tehelka editor Shoma Chaudhury and CNN-IBN managing editor Vinay Tewari point out, when you are sending a journalist on assignment to Chhattisgarh, it is the Naxal threat that you are briefing them on. It's only on location that they will learn that malaria is equally a hazard.
Media may be a flourishing industry, but once you begin to look closer, particularly at the armies of news gatherers in the regional media, it becomes clear that it is an unorganized and exploitative one. In a country where the bulk of small-town journalists are unlikely to get proper appointment letters, expecting health and risk protection for this category of workers is a pipe dream. The highest circulated newspaper in the country says it employs around 5,000 journalists and 7,000-odd stringers. Can the latter, who don't even get salaries, expect any kind of hazard protection?
Journalism can be a safe profession or a dangerous one depending on the kind of journalism you do. Tehelka has come in for criticism following this tragedy but Chaudhury says you have to take a call based on the reasonable risk doctrine. "Anyone pushing the line a bit on what journalism is will run a risk." Can Indian news organizations prepare their staff better? She says no Delhi editor can assess adequately the risks associated with the local terrain, but Tehelka will now look at issuing standing instructions on reporters making contact with a local doctor and local reporters. It will also look at the issue of insurance for its journalists.
In terms of equipping, insuring and briefing journalists, the gap between the first and third worlds is huge. Indian journalism in parts may be on par with the best, but news organization culture in this respect lags far behind. The BBC's high-risk policy runs into 14 pages. It has a high-risk team which can brief teams going out on hazards in different parts of the world. But, says Chaudhury, "This was not some other part of the world. This is our backyard. We thought we knew it."
The Hindu editor Siddharth Varadarajan says it's clear that Indian media will have to institutionalize safe practices of different kinds. His paper gives open-ended medical insurance, CNN-IBN says it provides bullet-proof jackets to its entire bureau in Srinagar, including outdoor broadcasting engineers and video journalists. It has insurance for all newsroom staff and a corpus to cover news staff when accidents occur. But even so, CNN International is on another planet. They had an armoured personnel carrier for their journalists in Iraq!
When the war is in your backyard and you don't have the UK or the US budgets, you do other things. Varadarajan says that when the local police made things hot for their Chhattisgarh correspondent, he had to take up the matter with the chief minister. Both he and Tewari are also clear that safety comes before risk. The latter says CNN-IBN tells reporters to eschew the romanticism of capturing a face-covered Naxal on camera, because the risk may not be worth it. But, and here's the final point, a driven reporter is often more committed to the pursuit of a story than the editor. In the interests of safety, she has to be reined in.

Sevanti Ninan is a media critic, author and editor of the media watch website thehoot.org. She examines the larger issues related to the media in a fortnightly column.